Lindsay Peat and Paula Fitzpatrick both touched down as the Ireland’s women overcame ever-improving Italy 14-3 to record their second win at Donnybrook in this year's Women's Six Nations.
Ireland Women's coach Tom Tierney's reaction to the game (which can be watched here in full)
(Report from IRFU) Prop Lindsay Peat's first international try, seven minutes before half-time, steadied the ship at 7-3 after a disjointed opening quarter from the hosts. Ireland's experienced bench had the desired impact, with back rower Paula Fitzpatrick scoring from a 64th minute maul. Tom Tierney's side, who are out of the Six Nations title race, wrap up their campaign at home to Scotland next Sunday.
Tierney handed debuts to Kim Flood at full-back and Liz Burke on the right wing today, while centre Claire McLaughlin's second half introduction brought the number of new caps to 14 since last November. Expanding Ireland's international player pool is a key objective for the management team ahead of the Women's Rugby World Cup on home soil next year. Bedding in new players and combinations takes time and it was not until the second quarter that Ireland really settled down after the fired-up Italians had dominated the initial exchanges.
Italy's streetwise forwards lorded the early possession and territory, going close from a powerful maul five metres out and then turning over an Irish scrum in front of the posts. A Ciara Cooney lineout steal relieved the pressure slightly, but Ireland's discipline at the breakdown was poor and Peat was punished for hands in the ruck with Michela Sillari nailing a 12th minute kick for the opening points.
Ireland were very fortunate to avoid the concession of a try towards the end of the first quarter, a quick tap from the Azzurre catching them off guard and they went close in the left corner after Nikki Caughey was charged down.
Ireland's more experienced players then stepped up, with the returning Alison Miller and Sophie Spence - playing at number 8 - spearheading a break from deep, but a general lack of cohesion, including a series of frustrating knock-ons, meant they were unable to build much momentum in attack.
That was until flanker Cooney blocked an Italian clearance kick, sparking Ireland's best attacking spell of the half. Sene Naoupu was hauled down just short by Manuela Furlan, and Spence gained a couple more metres before Peat - making her first start for Ireland - muscled her way over just to the right of the posts.
Niamh Briggs added the extras and 7-3 is how it stayed up to the interval, the captain turning down a long range kick at the posts before Italy again got in first to a couple of crucial breakdowns.
Handling errors continued to blight Ireland's play on the resumption, with an off-colour Briggs particularly guilty, and danger woman Miller was well marshalled out wide by the consistently well-positioned Maria Magatti. A missed touchfinder from a penalty also robbed the girls in green of an advanced position, and a knock-on by Marie Louise Reilly spoiled a decent spell of carrying from the pack in the Italian 22.
Briggs' centre partner Naoupu, Ireland's most effective runner with ball in hand was held up soon after, but Tierney's charges made a penalty advantage count from the resulting lineout as replacement Fitzpatrick was driven over in the right corner.
Nora Stapleton, who was also sprung from the bench, added a well-struck conversion for 14-3. That should have set Ireland up for a strong finish, but once more a combination of resolute Italian defence and Irish inaccuracies in attack meant that the try count remained at two.
Ireland's ability to convert pressure into points was a hallmark of their play when winning two Championships in the last three years, but it has been sorely lacking for this new-look side so far this season.
They missed a couple of gilt-edged changes in the dying minutes, the otherwise impressive Flood taking the wrong option by straightening up when Burke was free out wide, and then replacement Claire Molloy was frustratingly held up short in the final play.
Newcomers Flood and Burke, who did very little wrong - particularly in defence, were among the positives on the day, as well as a plentiful return from the set piece where Peat, Cliodhna Moloney, Ailis Egan and Reilly were all prominent, and flankers Cooney and Ciara Griffin made some eye-catching tackles and solved some of the breakdown issues.
TIME LINE: 12 minutes - Italy penalty: Michela Sillari - 0-3; 33 mins - Ireland try: Lindsay Peat - 5-3; conversion: Niamh Briggs - 7-3; Half-time - Ireland 7 Italy 3; 64 mins - Ireland try: Paula Fitzpatrick - 12-3; conversion: Nora Stapleton - 14-3; Full-time - Ireland 14 Italy 3
Ireland Women Lineups Kim Flood (Railway Union/Leinster); Liz Burke (UL Bohemians/Munster), Niamh Briggs (UL Bohemians/Munster) (capt), Sene Naoupu (Galwegians/Connacht), Alison Miller (Portlaoise/Connacht); Nikki Caughey (Railway Union/Ulster), Mary Healy (Galwegians/Connacht); Lindsay Peat (Railway Union/Leinster), Cliodhna Moloney (Railway Union/Leinster), Ailis Egan (Old Belvedere/Leinster), Elaine Anthony (Highfield/Munster), Marie Louise Reilly (Old Belvedere/Leinster), Ciara Cooney (Railway Union/Leinster), Ciara Griffin (Tralee/Munster), Sophie Spence (Old Belvedere/Leinster).
Replacements used: Larissa Muldoon (Skewen) for Healy, Nora Stapleton (Old Belvedere/Leinster) for Caughey (both 51 mins), Ruth O'Reilly (Galwegians/Connacht) for Peat (54), Paula Fitzpatrick (Toulouse) for Spence, Claire McLaughlin (Queen's University/Ulster) for Briggs (both 59), Zoe Grattage (Tralee/Munster) for Moloney, Claire Molloy (Bristol) for Cooney (both 65), Fiona Reidy (UL Bohemians/Munster) for Miller (69), Miller for Egan (76).
Italy Women Lineups Manuela Furlan (Benetton Rugby Treviso); Maria Magatti (Rugby Monza 1949), Maria Grazia Cioffi (US Rugby Benevento), Michela Sillari (Rugby Colorno), Sofia Stefan (Rennes); Beatrice Rigoni (Valsugana Rugby Padova), Sara Barattin (Rugby Casale) (capt); Elisa Cucchiella (Belve Neroverdi), Lucia Cammarano (Rugby Monza 1949), Melissa Bettoni (Rennes), Elisa Pillotti (Rugby Parabiago), Alice Trevisan (Rugby Riviera Del Brenta), Michela Este (Benetton Rugby Treviso), Isabella Locatelli (Rugby Monza 1949), Elisa Giordano (Valsugana Rugby Padova).
Replacements used: Lucia Gai (Rugby Riviera Del Brenta) for Bettoni (35 mins), Valentina Ruzza (Valsugana Rugby Padova) for Pillotti (64), Bettoni for Cammarano (68-76, temp sub), Ilaria Arrighetti (Rennes) for Este (69), Paola Zangirolami (Valsugana Rugby Padova) for Stefan, Gaia Giacomoli (Rugby Colorno) for Cucchiella (both 73), Diletta Nicoletti (Rugby Bologna 1928) for Giacomoli (80+3). Not used: Silvia Folli (Valsugana Rugby Padova), Veronica Madia (Rugby Colorno).